
$399,000
Active4351 Bay Beach Lane #332, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Condominium
MLS #2026040766
MLS ID #2026040766, Jenny Beach, John R. Wood Properties
Fort Myers Beach, Florida
Fort Myers Beach is rebuilding, and buying here calls for equal parts imagination and careful review. The beach lifestyle remains compelling, but every property has its own construction and recovery story.
687 matching properties
View all Fort Myers Beach homes →
4351 Bay Beach Lane #332, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Condominium
MLS #2026040766
MLS ID #2026040766, Jenny Beach, John R. Wood Properties

191 Bahia Viaduct, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Residential
MLS #2026035983
MLS ID #2026035983, Jacob Eister, Apollo Coastal Realty LLC

18850 San Carlos Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
SpecialPurpose
MLS #2025018091
MLS ID #2025018091, Alexis Hansen May, KW Florida Living

8010 Estero Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Residential
MLS #2026006916
MLS ID #2026006916, Jacob Eister, Desirae Cragin, Apollo Coastal Realty LLC

175 Bahia Viaduct, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Residential
MLS #2026023063
MLS ID #2026023063, Jacob Eister, Desirae Cragin, Apollo Coastal Realty LLC

1041 3rd Street, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Unimproved Land
MLS #224067541
MLS ID #224067541, Anna Birkart, LoKation

180 Donora Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Residential
MLS #226033301
MLS ID #226033301, J Alex King, Bettina Koss, Premiere Plus Realty Company

612 Estero Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Residential
MLS #2026041296
MLS ID #2026041296, Tom Kiddy, P.A., The Keyes Company

2100 Estero Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Hotel/Motel
MLS #2026000177
MLS ID #2026000177, Christian Loffreno, Loffreno Real Estate, Inc.

2096 ESTERO Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Unimproved Land
MLS #2025026407
MLS ID #2025026407, Christian Loffreno, Loffreno Real Estate, Inc.

22491 Buccaneer Lagoon Street, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Residential
MLS #226034867
MLS ID #226034867, J Alex King, Bettina Koss, Premiere Plus Realty Company

740 Matanzas Court, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
Residential
MLS #226019058
MLS ID #226019058, J Alex King, Meagan Belger, Premiere Plus Realty Company
Living here
Fort Myers Beach is rebuilding, and buying here calls for equal parts imagination and careful review. The beach lifestyle remains compelling, but every property has its own construction and recovery story.
The island ranges from the livelier north end to quieter stretches farther south. Walking, boating and beach access can be excellent, while seasonal traffic and bridge access remain part of island life.
Condominiums, cottages, elevated homes and new construction all appear in the market. Confirm permits, elevation, flood zone, insurance, association finances and the status of surrounding properties.
Current conditions can change block by block. Visit in person and rely on current property documents rather than older assumptions about the neighborhood.
Closer to Times Square, Matanzas Pass, dining and the bridge to the mainland.
Residential streets and beach access between the island's livelier and quieter ends.
Condominiums, boating and a quieter setting near Big Carlos Pass.
Canals, docks and boating access where water depth and routes need property-specific review.
Explore more closely
Start with the parts of Fort Myers Beach that best match the way you want to live, then compare homes and carrying costs with the full city in view.
Explore nearby
A short drive can change the pace, the water access and the kind of home available. Keep these nearby communities in the conversation.
FAQ
Median home prices in Fort Myers Beach, Florida shift with the season and inventory mix. A Bean Group agent can pull current comparable sales for any neighborhood within Fort Myers Beach.
Buyer demand in Fort Myers Beach, Florida varies by price band and property type. A Bean Group agent can review current listing and sales activity with you before you write an offer.
Days-on-market in Fort Myers Beach fluctuates seasonally. A Bean Group agent can review the most recent sales activity with you.
Property taxes in Fort Myers Beach are set locally and reassessed periodically. Current rates are published by the municipality; a Bean Group agent can point you to the official figures for any home you're considering.
Request a free, no-obligation home valuation from a Bean Group agent. We combine recent sales data with an in-person walk-through to give you a defensible number — not an algorithmic guess.
Get in touch
Send a note and a Bean Group agent will follow up about buying or selling in Fort Myers Beach.