17 Key Street

About this home

Once known as the R.M. Tuttle House, a beautifully preserved 1880 Italianate style Victorian set on .44 acres in town. A large horseshoe driveway welcomes you home, while the charming covered porch invites you into a bright sunporch and welcoming foyer beyond. Inside, classic New England craftsmanship shines through soaring ceilings, tall windows, decorative trim, built-ins, and elegant architectural details. The spacious first floor offers a formal dining room, office, large living room with marble fireplace, updated half bath, and a stunning renovated kitchen featuring sage-green cabinetry, butcher block island with seating, stainless steel appliances, professional-style gas range, solid-surface countertops, and abundant natural light. A generous butler's pantry/laundry room with sink provides exceptional storage and workspace. A first-floor bedroom suite with private entrance, deck, and full bath offers flexibility for guests or primary-level living. Choose from two staircases to reach the second floor, where five additional bedrooms and a beautifully updated full bath await, complete with a large walk-in shower and clawfoot soaking tub. Major system updates were completed in 2006, blending modern convenience with historic character. Most furnishings and contents will convey, making this an exceptional turnkey opportunity. Outside, mature trees, established landscaping, and a vintage greenhouse ready for restoration create a storybook setting. Watch Eastport's famous Fourth of July Parade from your own spacious yard, then stroll just minutes to Historic Water Street, the business district, and the working waterfront. Located in the easternmost city in the United States, Eastport offers breathtaking ocean views, world-class tides, whale watching, boating, hiking, a thriving arts community, and an authentic Downeast Maine lifestyle. Historic charm, coastal beauty, and modern comfort come together in this remarkable home.