This property is no longer actively marketed. The last publicly available listing details are shown below; contact us for current availability.
About this home
Sophisticated Katama Retreat with Pool and Custom Finishes - Tucked at the end of a lightly traveled road, this modern farmhouse blends sophisticated design, generous living spaces, and exceptional backyard privacy. Thoughtfully customized by the owners in collaboration with the builder, the home features distinctive design details and elevated finishes throughout. A dramatic wall of glass fills the open-concept great room with natural light and connects seamlessly to the outdoor entertaining areas. Spacious living and dining spaces are anchored by a gas fireplace and custom built-ins. The chef’s kitchen features marble countertops, commercial-style stainless and integrated appliances, an oversized center island, beverage refrigerator, and sliding glass panels opening to a poolside bar. A luxurious first-floor primary suite, private office, laundry area, and powder room complete the main level. The home offers five bedrooms and four-and-one-half baths, including a second en suite primary bedroom upstairs. Two additional upper-level bedrooms share a well-designed Jack-and-Jill bath. The finished lower level includes a fifth bedroom, full bath, and expansive game/media room with pool and ping-pong tables, providing flexible space for guests and recreation. Outside, the property becomes a private resort-style retreat with a heated 16-by-38-foot gunite saltwater pool and generous sun shelf. An expansive bluestone patio offers multiple lounge and dining areas, a fire table, and a separate wood-burning fire pit. Manicured grounds, thoughtful landscaping, broad lawn areas, and an enclosed outdoor shower complete the setting. With a strong rental income history, the property offers compelling potential for personal enjoyment and investment. Offered turnkey with indoor and outdoor furnishings for immediate enjoyment or continued rental use.
Listing last checked: Listing updated:
Listed by Wendy Harman · Compass · MLS #73569858
Request property information
Select a document to start a request. You can add others in the form. Availability varies.
Details at a glance
Interior5 property facts
- Rooms
- 8
- Heating
- Forced Air, Natural Gas
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Basement
- Yes · Full, Finished, Interior Entry
- Fireplaces
- 1
Building4 property facts
- Style
- Single Family Residence
- Year built
- 2021
- Parking
- 4
- Foundation
- Concrete Perimeter
Land & utilities5 property facts
- Lot size
- 0.96 acres
- Water
- Private
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
- Pool
- Yes · Pool - Inground Heated, Private
- Zoning
- R20
Financial2 property facts
- Annual taxes
- $8,190
- Assessment year
- 2026
Location
More property insights
Automated value estimate $5,321,867
Estimated range $4,770,298–$5,873,436.
Automated estimates are not appraisals or guarantees of market value.
Request a professional market analysisPhoto-based condition insights
Overall presentation: excellent
Explore more of Edgartown
Continue your search in Edgartown.
Need help making sense of this home?
About 37 Plain Field Way
Is this home available for a showing?
This home is no longer actively marketed. Ask our team about its current status or similar homes.
Can you help me evaluate this property?
Yes. We can discuss condition, comparable sales, offer strategy and the questions worth asking before you decide whether to proceed.
Are property documents available?
Availability varies by property and source. Request the documents you need and we will help obtain what is available.

