Sold Jun 21, 2026$586,500
Active
9 58th St
Newburyport, MA 01950
$649,900
3Bedrooms
1Bathrooms
1,020Square feet
1950Year built
Residential · Active · MLS #73568829
Listing Courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Evolution | Barb Cullen
MLS PIN data
About this home
Fall in love with this irresistibly charming, west-facing Plum Island cottage—a treasured family retreat for decades and the sweetest setting for relaxed island living. The inviting front porch offers a front-row seat to Plum Island’s spectacular sunsets, while the basin is just steps away for launching a kayak or canoe. The ocean and sandy dune beach are only one street away. Inside, two full walls of windows fill the cheerful, open-concept L-shaped living & dining area with amazing natural light and create an inviting space for gathering after a day at the beach. The thoughtfully designed kitchen maximizes cabinet, pantry & dish storage, while three cozy bedrooms and a 3/4 bathroom with shower provide comfortable accommodations. All windows throughout the home are newer vinyl replacements. The property also offers private outdoor space, a storage shed and parking for six cars. The cottage is currently enjoyed seasonally, from approximately April through November. A newer ductless mini-split in the main living area provides heating & cooling but is not considered sufficient for the coldest winter months. The water heater is also newer. Former propane heating units have been disconnected and the propane tanks removed. A vintage plug-in washing machine remains in working condition; with clothesline space in the backyard. You will have an exciting array of possibilities: enjoy this delightful cottage just as it is, thoughtfully improve and update it for year-round living, or explore the potential to create an entirely new island home, much like the recently rebuilt contemporary residence next door. Any renovations, expansion or new construction would be subject to all applicable permitting and approvals. Lovingly held by the same family for generations, this enchanting island haven is now ready for you to begin living your dreams at the beach. Easy to show!
Property information
Details at a glance
Interior
- Rooms
- 7
- Heating
- Ductless
- Cooling
- Ductless
- Flooring
- Wood, Vinyl, Carpet
Building
- Style
- Single Family Residence
- Year built
- 1950
- Parking
- 6
- Foundation
- Other
- Roof
- Shingle
Land & utilities
- Lot size
- 0.1 acres
- Water
- Public
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
- Zoning
- RES
Financial
- Annual taxes
- $5,107
- Assessment year
- 2026
Listing history
Price and status timeline
No additional public listing history was supplied for this property.
Property value estimate
An informed starting point
Automated estimates are not appraisals or guarantees of market value.
Comparable sales
Recent properties for context
Sold Jul 21, 2026$600,000
16 Baremeadow St
Sold Jul 13, 2026$647,500
90 Lowell St
Photo insights
Condition signals
Overall presentationabove average
Generated from listing photography; not a substitute for an inspection.
Local market context
How this home compares in Plum Island
MetricThis propertyPlum Island
List price$649,900$1,490,00056% below local
Price / sq ft$637$83724% below local
Days on market88390% below local
Active neighborhood listing statistics from MLS PIN as of September 7, 2026. Asking prices are not completed-sale values.
Keep exploring
Similar homes nearby
Same city and within 25% of the asking price, matched by property type and bedroom count when available and ranked by size and price.
No close matches are available right now. Browse all homes in Newburyport.
Bean Group guidance
Visit this home
Upcoming open house
Mon, Sep 7 · 11:00 AM–12:30 PM
Register and we’ll send the available property information so you arrive informed. There is no obligation to attend and registration does not create an agency relationship.
Useful next steps
Request property information
Select a document or report and Bean Group will help track it down.
Availability varies by property and source. Documents are requested from the appropriate source and may not be immediately available.
Considering this property?
Decide whether it deserves a closer look.
A local Bean Group agent can help you compare nearby inventory, understand the listing details, and identify the questions worth answering before you visit.
Common questions
About 9 58th St
Can I schedule a private showing?
Yes. Request a tour of 9 58th St and a Bean Group agent will help coordinate an available time with the listing side.
Can you help me evaluate this property?
Yes. We can discuss condition, comparable sales, offer strategy and the questions worth asking before you decide whether to proceed.
Are property documents available?
Availability varies by property and source. Request the documents you need and we will help obtain what is available.